Why is the Fed Tightening Credit But Not Money?
It has not removed any significant percentage of the trillions in new dollars created since 2020
Federal Reserve Board Chairman Jay Powell surprised no one on Wednesday by announcing the Fed has raised its target for the federal funds rate another 50 basis points to the 4.25% – 4.50% range. What did surprise the stock markets, based upon the sharp selloff following his remarks, was his statement,
“Restoring price stability is essential to set the stage for achieving maximum employment and stable prices over the longer run. The historical record cautions strongly against prematurely loosening policy. We will stay the course, until the job is done”
That’s basically what he has said during every public announcement since embarking on an historically steep round of interest rate hikes over the past six months. That this surprised investors indicates how deeply ingrained the “Fed put” has become in the psyche of the financial community. The stock markets continue to fluctuate below their all-time highs, therefore everyone assumes the Fed will announce a “pivot” at the next meeting, since it always in the past.
So, as each meeting approaches, the market begins to rally in anticipation of an announcement or even a hint of said pivot at Powell’s press conference. Then, Powell reads the same statement he has given after every previous meeting and the market sells off.
Needless to say, this is a terrible way for capital to be allocated, even given the existence of a central bank in lieu of a free market. But over a decade of zero interest rate policy (ZIRP) has trained investors to act even more irrationally and for equity prices to become even more separated from fundamentals than they have been in the past.
The Fed’s Balance Sheet
Ironically, Powell made another statement which is demonstrably false and is receiving no attention from investors or the financial media. He said, “In addition, we are continuing the process of significantly reducing the size of our balance sheet.”
The Fed has not significantly reduced its balance sheet. Let’s remember that in August 2019, the Fed’s balance sheet stood at approximately $3.7 trillion, down from its peak of $4.4 trillion 2014-17. The Fed reversed its modest tightening policy and began easing, increasing its balance sheet to $4.1 trillion by February 2020.
Once the Covid-19 lockdowns began, the Fed exploded its balance sheet to over $7 trillion in just three months, eventually taking the total to $8.9 trillion by March 2022.
One would think that “significantly reducing the balance sheet” would mean something more than Powell’s announced plan to reduce it by a mere $45 billion per month June-August 2022 and then by $90 billion per month every month thereafter. But the Fed hasn’t even managed to do that. As of this writing, the Fed’s assets still total almost $8.6 trillion.
In other words, while the Fed has raised the federal funds rate significantly this year, it has not attempted to reduce the supply of money. As a result, M2 has barely decreased since its peak of $21.8 trillion in March 2022. And without decreasing the money supply, the Fed cannot significantly reduce price inflation anytime soon.
As I’ve reminded my podcast listeners many times, raising the federal funds rate and deceasing the money supply is no longer accomplished in the same operation as it was before 2008. Prior to that, the Fed’s methodology for raising the interest rate was to sell bonds to its member banks, which pulled dollars directly out of their operating cash and thereby out of the money supply.
Keep reading with a 7-day free trial
Subscribe to Tom Mullen Talks Freedom to keep reading this post and get 7 days of free access to the full post archives.